After being asked about why the Parkzone UM P-51 made it onto my "Avoid" list, I decided to post this "catch-up" mini-review. This article is a little different than most, I elected not to maintain my PZ UM P-51 since it never flew well for me.
The reasons for that are several. My mini Mustang was a squirrelly little bird anytime I strayed any real distance from center of the flight regime. I've read others who have had better experiences, but they might be more content dwell closer to the heart of the envelop than I am. Alternatively, it could be a quality control thing, as plenty of this old Ultra Micro design is prone to failure or misalignment.
Part of the problem stems from first generation Horizon Hobby UM construction, which was and often still is, unacceptably weak in key areas of the build. The vertical tail of the Mustang is very flimsy, as is the horizontal stabilizer. This is likely a source of inconsistency as well as substandard flight handling.
The silly-cheap under cambered airfoil is not well suited to the warbird theme of the plane, causing the pitch axis to become too unpredictable across a wide airspeed range. Air can billow asymmetrically in the pocket underneath at low speeds, resulting in some nasty stall behavior, while the wing can tuck at higher speeds as the lack of a true airfoil snags a variety of stability perturbations.
Additionally brushed can motor is unreliable over time, I've replaced many for various issues from internal failure to wires separating. The usual HH PCB micro servos are weak, slow, and unreliable with regular use, and the tail control horns tended to tear at the ultra-thin foam hinges as a result of normal wear and tear. The plane, like so many micros in its class, exhibits a definite half-life of decay whether you baby it or not..
Lastly, the P-51 design itself looks a lot better than it feels when out of its element. This was a plane designed for extreme efficiency and power at high altitudes and airspeeds. It is beautiful to look at, but it was never designed to be a pleasant low-speed ride. Quite the contrary, the WWII Mustang was always an aptly named, ornery steed in need of experienced taming during administrative flying.
It all adds up to a price that's way too high for the opportunity cost. My overall grade is: D+
Wednesday, August 3, 2011
Z8RC Open Discussion
Feedback | Suggestions | Questions
Please note, reader comments do not appear immediately after hitting submit.
Please note, reader comments do not appear immediately after hitting submit.
I like to fly:
Top 10 This Week
-
Two new Gee Bees are available at about the same fly-away price, it's time to compare the E-Flite UMX Gee Bee R-2 BNF (EFGBR2) to the ne...
-
Get ready for some hard WWI 3D action. Some ask, “Why?” I ask, “Why not?” PZ Albatros with Rimfire 15, 11x3.8 SF prop, HK Flight Stab...
-
Those who have read my blog article understand that testing an aircraft engine on a test stand in isolation never yields any information. ...
-
Page views I would like to thank those who visit Z8RC for a 10-fold increase in readership during a brief year of existence. Thank yo...
-
Walking out of an arts and crafts store, I couldn't resist this simple 50" Air Hog foam glider, sold in a bag for $6. http://www....
-
As I test fly, and quickly iterate the GP Yak-55M, one need that became very apparent was a wheel brake solution to operate this big boy out...
-
UPDATE: Also see: Half of DX8 users report "unresolved" problems UPDATE: Also see: Head to Head: Aurora 9 vs Spektrum DX8 ...
-
Update 2: The wind was blowing hard but I managed to get enough flying in to repeatedly juice the tail under full power. The P-51 motor ab...
-
Addendum: As a result of my review, Horizon lowered the price of the UMX Beast to $99, earning it a B+ Z8RC overall rating. Horizon deserv...
-
Update: After several more trips tot he field, I am upping the Mosquito's overall grade to A . Update: Added a discussion of slow flig...
Top 10 This Month
-
Update 3: See also: http://z8rc.blogspot.com/2012/01/blade-mcp-x-100-tail-blow-out-fix.html Update 2: mCP X with Z8RC truss upgraded to A...
-
The Hobby King P-38 did very well in my recent review - but that's even more reason to upgrade the airplane. The MAS 9x7x3-blade pus...
-
Completed model including guide wires, painted prop and 9 cylinder radial. Update 11: Paint and landing gear mods. I added two 2 mm c...
-
The E-flight UMX Extra 300 is a very lightweight half foam/half mylar offering in the indoor 3D arena (or to a much lesser extent and no win...
-
I picked up this cool 42" Dynam 72 MHz Hog for less than $120, a few bucks cheaper than the PnP version. Nothing my 2.4 GHz Rx spares ...
-
The Blade SR's twitchy tail takes getting used to, but the errors generally offset in a hover. The SR is a Collective Pitch lead-in tr...
-
With the latest surge in foam plane popularity, most serious hobbyists own at least one. The beauty of foam is the speed at which a decent ...
-
BlitzRCWorks G4 Quad Charger / Thunder T6 Multi Charger Update: My Common Sense RC 250W PSU has two sets of outputs (see photo below). ...
-
UPDATE 5: Added landing gear with a steerable nose. See Z8RC Mods, below. UPDATE 4: Added a rudder and thrust vectoring. See Z8RC Mods,...
-
Continuing and ending my mini-series on how to land, this article focuses on flying a good traffic pattern: the military Overhead. The Ove...
Z8RC Resources
A Practical RC Simulator Comparison
AMA Under the Microscope (& Part 2)
Balancing a ducted fan or prop perfectly
Balsa or Foam?
Blade mCP X 100% Vibration Fix
Choosing the Right Motor
FAA Guarantees Your Right to Fly RC in the USA
Fixing those broken UM wheel pants
How to Land from The Overhead Pattern
Online RC Discount Codes
Soft Throttle
Understanding CG
Z8RC Thrust-to-Weight Ratio Database
Z8RC Manufacturer Rankings